'A Woman Is Not One, But Many': Indian Women’s Lives Beyond Stereotypes

Often, discussions surrounding women's issues and equality inadvertently oversimplify the challenges faced by women, assuming a universal experience and shared aspirations. Contrary to this misconception, women are not a monolithic entity but rather a diverse group with intersecting identities influenced by factors such as class, caste, race, disability, and sexuality. These intersecting hierarchies create distinct challenges for women, resulting in disparities in their access to privileges and basic rights.

Beyond Homogeneity

Reflect on different parts of your identity—occupation, marital status, preferences like food or literature. Now, delve into fundamental aspects of it, such as gender, sexuality, caste, and religion, if you embrace one. It's essential to examine which aspects grant privilege and which lead to oppression in this context. Within the broader context of gender, the existence of hierarchies based on class, caste, race, and sexuality amplifies the struggles faced by women. Those situated in specific socio-economic strata find themselves devoid of privileges that others can assert. Unfortunately, the vast distances between these hierarchies often hinder women from marginalized backgrounds from asserting even their most basic human and fundamental rights.

Overlooked Realities Of Tribal Women

Examining these hierarchies sheds light on the unique challenges faced by different groups of women. For instance, tribal women, residing on the fringes of society, grapple with issues tied to their cultural identity and limited access to basic resources. From land rights to healthcare, their struggle demands a specialized focus that is often overlooked in mainstream discussions about gender equality.

The Urban-Rural Divide

Similarly, rural women encounter challenges distinct from their urban counterparts, including limited access to education, healthcare, and economic opportunities. For instance, healthcare accessibility is often a critical concern in rural settings. The scarcity of medical facilities and healthcare professionals in rural areas can lead to inadequate prenatal and postnatal care for women. Maternal health may be compromised due to the absence of proper infrastructure, leading to higher maternal mortality rates. Bridging the rural-urban gap becomes crucial to ensuring the voices of these women are heard and their specific needs are addressed. 

The Role Of Age & Sexual Orientation  

The challenges faced by older women are yet another facet of this complexity. Issues such as ageism, healthcare, and social isolation become prominent, necessitating a recognition of the diverse needs of different age groups within the female population. Adding another layer to this complex tapestry is sexual orientation, as queer women often face discrimination not only for their gender but also for their sexual identity. True gender equality requires acknowledging and addressing the unique challenges faced by the LGBTQ+ community.

Caste-Gender Overlap: The Hidden Hierarchy 

One particularly overlooked hierarchy, especially in the Indian context, is the intersection of caste and gender. Women belonging to certain castes find themselves in the most vulnerable positions within society, facing unique and often alarming experiences. This caste-gender overlap reveals a stark reality when compared to the perspectives of those who haven't faced such challenges.

Personal narratives often shape our understanding of these hierarchies. Raised in a predominantly conservative environment, I was exposed to deeply ingrained caste-based opinions and conversations. These discussions, originating from a position of privilege and ignorance, portrayed caste as prestigious and pure, influencing my early education and family values. Being the eldest daughter, my family emphasized the limitations and so-called caste boundaries in the context of marriage. 

I learned that discrimination can persist not only through structural factors like employment and education but also through the dominance of a certain mindset. Intersectionality recognizes the complexity and diversity of individuals' experiences, highlighting the need for an inclusive approach to social justice.

However, the common intersectional approach often neglects caste identities, a critical oversight. The inclusion of caste identities in conversations about intersectionality is as crucial as acknowledging racial identities. Caste hierarchies in India collectively polarize the identity of Dalit women, invalidating their oppression and reinforcing a close interface between caste, gender, and patriarchy.

In conclusion, recognizing and understanding these diverse hierarchies among women is crucial for crafting effective and inclusive solutions.  A woman is not one but many, and an intersectional approach is vital for addressing discrimination based on gender and its overlapping hierarchies in India

Personal views expressed by the author are their own

Suggested reading: Main Karun Toh Character Dheela Hai? Men Hailed But Women Ridiculed