H&M, the Swedish fashion giant, finds itself embroiled in controversy as it pulls an advertisement for school clothing in Australia. The move comes in response to widespread criticism alleging the ad's sexualisation of underage girls, prompting the brand to take swift action.
H&M's advertising campaign, launched in Australia, prominently featured two young girls in school uniforms, accompanied by the caption, “Make those heads turn in H&M’s Back to School fashion.” However, what seemed like a harmless promotion quickly escalated into a social media frenzy, with users expressing concern over the perceived inappropriate portrayal of minors.
The Controversial Campaign & Public Outcry
Social media platforms became the battleground for discontent, as users accused H&M of insensitivity in portraying young girls in a manner that could be construed as inappropriate. Melinda Tankard Reist, an Australian writer known for her activism against pornography, voiced her disapproval, stating, “The little girls’ parents generally prefer heads don’t ‘turn’ when others see their daughters walking to school, on a bus, or in class.”
@hm @hmaustralia what is your intention with this sponsored Facebook ad? Little schoolgirls generally don’t want to “turn heads”. The large numbers I engage with in schools want to be left alone to learn and have fun and not draw unwanted attention to their appearance 1/ pic.twitter.com/DDwv42GeNz
— Melinda TankardReist (@MelTankardReist) January 18, 2024
We are a culture lost to corporatism and pornification.
— Billy Bragg (@Serena_Partrick) January 18, 2024
This is sick.
It's deeper than just turning heads. The whole image is sexualised from the ethnicity of the girls, their pose and are their legs oiled?
— sasca sasca (@sascara) January 18, 2024
I'm guessing that the marketing team that came up with "Love's Baby Soft" is still in business after all these years. pic.twitter.com/wZwCLO68k7
— dbetzel_phd (@dbetzel) January 18, 2024
It Is So Completely Unnecessary to portray little girls as sex objects in pink rooms in your advertising! There are too many adult pedophiles who turn on such objectification of children! Don't give them fuel! No girl wants to be projected as a sex object!
— made_wonderful💗 (@made_wonderful_) January 22, 2024
This is really disturbing.
— Coralie Alison (@CoralieAlison) January 18, 2024
I remember being cat called whilst waiting for the bus in my school uniform. It made me feel unsafe.
Girls go to school to get an education, not to be jeered at by onlookers. #hmkids @hmaustralia @hm
H&M's Formal Apology and Industry-Wide Repercussions
This ad has now been removed. We are deeply sorry for the offense this has caused and will look into how we present campaigns going forward.
— H&M Customer Service (@hm_custserv) January 19, 2024
Acknowledging the gravity of the situation, an H&M spokesperson issued a formal apology on Monday, confirming the removal of the contentious ad. The spokesperson stated, “We have removed this ad. We are deeply sorry for the offense this has caused, and we are thoroughly examining our approach to future campaigns.”
H&M's predicament is not an isolated occurrence. The fashion industry has recently witnessed a series of controversies surrounding advertising campaigns. Zara faced backlash for an insensitive campaign depicting a model amid rubble and mannequins wrapped in shrouds, resulting in the withdrawal of the campaign.
Balenciaga, a Paris-based luxury fashion brand, issued an apology last year for running ads featuring children holding teddy bears wearing bondage-style attire. The ads included a printout of a Supreme Court decision upholding laws against child pornography, raising ethical concerns within the industry
According to the BBC, Temu, a Chinese-owned online marketplace, came under fire in 2023 after advertising sexualising a youngster. According to the Advertising Standards Authority, the photograph portrayed a girl aged eight to ten wearing a bikini in a position that was "quite adult for a girl her age."
These incidents prompt a broader reflection on the role of fashion brands in shaping societal perceptions, especially concerning the portrayal of children in advertising.
The Call for Responsible Advertising
As consumers become more conscientious about the content they endorse, brands face an increasing demand for socially responsible advertising. The H&M incident is a stark reminder that missteps in marketing can lead to swift and severe public backlash. The industry must learn from such controversies and strive for a balance between creativity and responsibility. Brands that prioritise sensitivity and inclusivity in their messaging are likely to resonate more positively with their audience in an era where consumers scrutinize brands for their ethical stance.
Personal views expressed by the author are their own