Russia: Conservative Reality Of Abortion Restrictions Sparks Outrage

In Russia, a country known for its immense landmass and diverse culture, the issue of abortion is once again gaining attention. Despite its seemingly abrupt scheduling, a meeting in Kaliningrad, the westernmost city of Russia, served as a stark reminder of the ongoing struggle over women's reproductive rights. Approximately 60 individuals gathered in a local bookstore, their concern stemming from a lawmaker's bid to ban abortions in private clinics.

The unexpected turnout for a weeknight gathering provided a glimmer of hope for activists like Dasha Yakovleva, co-founder of the Feminitive Community women's group. Yakovleva aptly noted, "Right now, there is no room for political action in Russia. The only place left is our kitchens."

While abortion remains legally accessible in Russia, it's crucial to address the recent attempts to restrict it, as they resonate with the country's shift towards conservatism. Activists, recognizing the significance of the matter, are taking decisive steps, encouraging supporters to file official complaints, rallying online petitions, and even staging small protests.

A 'Gradual Erosion' Of Abortion Access

The situation in Kaliningrad is but a glimpse of a broader issue. Private clinics in various parts of the country have already ceased to provide abortion services. Nationally, the Health Ministry has drafted guidelines for medical professionals to dissuade women from terminating their pregnancies. Furthermore, impending regulations are set to render many emergency contraceptives almost inaccessible and inflate their costs.

Michele Rivkin-Fish, an anthropologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, draws a concerning parallel and told the Associated Press: "It's clear that there is a gradual erosion of abortion access and rights in Russia, and this is similar to what has taken place in the U.S." The reference to the United States is noteworthy, especially in the wake of a Supreme Court decision that reshaped abortion policy and transferred power to individual states. In fact, approximately half of U.S. states have imposed bans or severe restrictions, albeit facing legal challenges.

A Historical Perspective: From The Soviet Union To Putin's Russia

To comprehend the gravity of the issue, it's essential to consider Russia's historical context. In the Soviet Union, stringent abortion laws often led women to undergo the procedure multiple times due to the difficulty of obtaining contraceptives. However, with the collapse of the USSR, government initiatives and health education campaigns led to a decline in abortion rates. The legal framework also allowed women to terminate pregnancies up to 12 weeks without any conditions and, in many cases, up to 22 weeks for various "social reasons."

Yet, this landscape shifted under the leadership of Vladimir Putin, who has cultivated a strong alliance with the Russian Orthodox Church and actively promoted "traditional values" while striving to boost population growth. Health Minister Mikhail Murashko publicly criticized women for prioritizing education and careers over childbearing. Consequently, over the decades, the number of abortions in Russia has decreased significantly, dropping from 4.1 million in 1990 to 517,000 in 2021.

Restrictions And Psychological Burdens

Presently, only instances of rape allow abortions between 12 and 22 weeks. Some regions observe "Days of Silence" when public clinics do not provide abortion services. Women must endure waiting periods of 48 hours or even a week, depending on the stage of their pregnancy, in case they reconsider their decision. They are also subjected to psychological consultations designed to discourage abortions, as outlined in state-issued guidelines. These waiting periods can be psychologically distressing for many patients.

A particularly troubling practice involves referring women to a priest before granting permission for an abortion in some state clinics. While authorities argue that the consultation is voluntary, some women have reported feeling pressured to involve a priest in the process.

The Battle Over Abortion Pills

The anti-abortion push in Russia comes at a time when many women are hesitating to have more children, influenced by the ongoing conflict in Ukraine and economic uncertainty. Sales of abortion pills surged by 60% in 2022, while they have dropped by 35% this year but still remain higher than pre-2022 levels. Contraceptive medication sales have also increased in 2022–23.

A recent Health Ministry decree has further complicated matters by imposing restrictions on the circulation of abortion pills used in the first trimester. The decree categorizes mifepristone and misoprostol, the key ingredients in these pills, as controlled substances, necessitating meticulous record-keeping and storage. While hospitals and clinics, where these pills are typically dispensed, may face more paperwork, the real impact is expected on the availability of emergency contraceptives, commonly known as morning-after pills.

The Future Of Abortion In Private Clinics

Senior lawmaker Pyotr Tolstoy has indicated that a nationwide ban on abortions in private clinics is under consideration. In recent years, about 20% of abortions took place in such facilities, according to state statistics. Conservative lawmakers have previously failed to enact such a ban, but the current climate appears more receptive to this idea. Irina Volynets, an abortion opponent and children's rights ombudswoman in the Tatarstan region, sees potential in this move and hopes that private clinics will eventually cease offering abortions.

Regional authorities have also taken steps to persuade private clinics to discontinue abortion services, with varying levels of success. The pressure on women to carry pregnancies to term is expected to intensify, even if a total ban doesn't materialize. Public opinion, as exemplified by the 27,000 signatures gathered against the ban in Kaliningrad, reflects the enduring determination to safeguard reproductive rights.

The Ethical Dilemma In Doctor-Patient Conversations

The Health Ministry's pilot project in seven regions involves gynaecologists attempting to dissuade women from having abortions. An internal document outlines the language doctors are encouraged to use, praising pregnancy as "a beautiful and natural condition for every woman" while labelling abortion as "harmful to your health and a risk of developing complications."

While some women may appreciate these conversations when facing uncertainty, they can be deeply uncomfortable for others. This approach raises ethical questions about the doctor-patient relationship and autonomy.

Dr Lyubov Yeroveyeva, a gynaecologist with a history of spearheading family planning projects, advocates for a different approach. She emphasises the importance of preventing unwanted pregnancies through education about birth control and making contraceptives widely available. Instead of coercing women away from abortion, the focus should be on providing the support and resources necessary to make informed choices.

The situation in Russia paints a bleak picture of women's reproductive rights. The gradual erosion of abortion access, coupled with increased restrictions on abortion pills and the potential nationwide ban on private clinic abortions, underscores the challenges women face in making decisions about their own bodies.

Suggested reading: Abortion Prison Sentence Shows Law Is Focused On Foetuses: Why It Is Dangerous For Women